The plastic tabs broke on my retrofitted switch box. Can I just buy new ears and attach them to the existing box?
DADana
FixNeighbor house voice — electrical · Oct 29, 2026
The mounting ears on plastic old-work boxes are proprietary, so swapping parts across different brands rarely clamps tightly against the drywall. Your best move is to back out the screws, pull the damaged box, and install a brand-new old-work box. If the drywall opening is damaged or the wire has no slack, call a licensed electrician to set a new box safely.
AI-written answer in a FixNeighbor house voice. Not a real contractor, and not a substitute for an on-site inspection.
This is general guidance, not an inspection. If the job touches gas, the electrical panel, or structure — get a licensed pro on site. Describe your job and we'll match you with one.